Back to the library
Chargebacks & Disputes
2026-11-20 10 min read

Defective Goods and Visa's 13.3 Dispute Rules

Under Visa 13.3 the customer must return or try to return first, and an attempt only counts in five situations. Four of them are your own doing.

JA

By Jeffrey Anderson

chargebacksvisa rulesdispute 13.3returnsecommerce
Defective Goods and Visa's 13.3 Dispute Rules
Key takeaways
  • Section 11.11.4.2 (ID# 0030326) requires the cardholder to return or attempt to return before the issuer may initiate, and an attempt is valid only where the merchant refused the return, refused an authorization or label, told the cardholder not to return, no longer exists or is not responding, or did not give clear return instructions.
  • Four of those five triggers are merchant conduct, so an unclear returns page is enough to validate a dispute from a customer who never shipped anything back.
  • Section 11.11.4.3 (ID# 0030327) makes the dispute invalid for price discrepancies, VAT, fuel dispenser transactions, crypto that simply failed to appreciate, and the quality of restaurant food, where Visa's own example is a burger received cold.
  • In the US and Canada a card-absent dispute also lies where the merchant's verbal description did not match what arrived, so phone sales descriptions are in scope even though nothing was written down.
  • Refusing a cancellation, a return or a credit removes the issuer's 15 calendar day waiting period, and a negotiation starting within 120 days of the processing date gives the issuer 60 calendar days from the first cardholder notification instead of the usual window.
  • Under Section 11.11.4.6 (ID# 0030330) the substantive response needs both evidence that the goods matched the description or were not defective and a merchant rebuttal to the cardholder's claims, unlike 13.1 where proof of delivery stands alone.

Defective goods and quality complaints come through Dispute Condition 13.3, and the rule gives merchants something 13.1 does not: the cardholder has to return the merchandise, or attempt to, before the issuer may raise a dispute at all. A mere attempt counts only in five situations, and four of them are entirely your doing.

Section 11.11.4.2 of the Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (ID# 0030326) says an attempt to return is valid only when the merchant did one of the following:

  • Refused the return of the merchandise
  • Refused to provide a return merchandise authorization or label
  • Instructed the cardholder not to return the merchandise
  • No longer exists or is not responding to the cardholder
  • Did not provide clear instructions on how to return

Read the last one twice. An unclear returns page is enough to turn a customer who never shipped anything back into a valid dispute. That is the cheapest 13.3 defence available and it is a documentation job, not a dispute job.

What 13.3 Actually Covers

Section 11.11.4.1 (ID# 0030325) allows the dispute where the merchandise or services did not match what was described on the transaction receipt or another record presented at purchase, where what arrived was damaged or defective, or where the cardholder disputes the quality of what they received.

There is a US-specific reason on top of those. For a card-absent transaction in the US, Canada, or between the two, the dispute also applies where "the Merchant's verbal description or other documentation presented at the time of purchase did not match the merchandise or services received."

Verbal. If your sales team describes a product on a phone call, that description is a dispute basis in the US even though it appears nowhere in writing. Call recordings stop being a nice-to-have at that point.

Ten Ways the Dispute Is Invalid

Section 11.11.4.3 (ID# 0030327) is the defence list, and it is different from the one under 13.1:

  • An ATM cash disbursement
  • A straight through processing transaction
  • A dispute regarding Value-Added Tax
  • Returned merchandise held by any customs agency except the merchant's country's customs agency
  • The cash-back portion of a cash-back transaction
  • A transaction the cardholder states is fraudulent
  • An automated fuel dispenser transaction
  • A dispute regarding a price discrepancy
  • Crypto or an NFT that "does not increase in resale value as the Cardholder expected"

And one with Visa's own illustration attached: "A Dispute regarding the quality of food received from eating places or restaurants (for example: the burger was received cold)".

So restaurants are outside 13.3 on food quality. A cold burger is not a chargeback. Price complaints are out too, which surprises people, and so is VAT.

The crypto pair is worth holding together. A dispute lies where the merchant "guaranteed to increase in value" the asset, under Section 11.11.4.2. A dispute is invalid where the asset simply did not appreciate as the cardholder hoped. The promise creates the liability, not the price chart.

The Clock, and the Route That Extends It

Section 11.11.4.4 (ID# 0030328) sets two paths, and most summaries only mention the first.

The issuer must wait 15 calendar days from the date the cardholder returned, attempted to return, or cancelled. That waiting period disappears if waiting would push the dispute past its own deadline, or "if the Merchant refuses to accept the cancellation, the return, or refuses to issue a credit." Refusing a return costs you the buffer.

Then the outer limits. A dispute must be processed within 120 calendar days of either the transaction processing date or the date the cardholder received the merchandise or services, capped by footnote at 540 calendar days from the processing date.

The second path is the one to know about. A dispute may instead be processed within 60 calendar days of the date the issuer received the first cardholder notification, if both of these hold: there is evidence in the notification of previous ongoing negotiations between the cardholder and the merchant, and those negotiations occurred within 120 days of the transaction processing date.

That means a long customer-service conversation can keep the window open past the usual 120 days. If you are negotiating with an unhappy customer at day 110, the clock you are working against may be the 60-day one running from whenever they eventually call their bank. Resolve it or decline it, but do not let it drift.

What the Issuer Has to Certify

Section 11.11.4.5 (ID# 0030329) lists the issuer's burden, and two items became effective on 24 October 2026, so they are current obligations in this edition rather than things to wait for.

Effective 24 October 2026, for quality issues at a lodging merchant, the issuer must certify the date of the cardholder's check-out. Also effective that date, for merchandise the issuer must give "a detailed description of the merchandise purchased" going beyond the clearing record, and Visa illustrates it the same way it does under 13.1: the merchant's MCC is 5651 Family Clothing Stores and the description states a pair of blue jeans.

The rest of the certification runs: an explanation of what was not as described or defective, the date the cardholder received the goods, that the cardholder attempted to resolve with the merchant, and for services the date the cardholder cancelled or requested a credit. For returned merchandise the issuer gives the shipping company and tracking number where available plus the date you received it. For an attempted return the issuer must give a detailed explanation of how and when, the disposition of the merchandise, and certification of which of those five merchant failures applied.

For the negotiation route the issuer must certify the date negotiations began, the date it was first notified, and provide evidence of the negotiations themselves.

Your Response Needs Two Things, Not One

Section 11.11.4.6 (ID# 0030330) accepts a few single-item responses: a credit or reversal you issued that the issuer did not address, that the dispute is invalid, or that the cardholder no longer disputes the transaction.

But the main substantive defence requires both of the following together:

  • Evidence to prove that the merchandise or service matched what was described, including the description of the quality, or was not damaged or defective
  • Merchant rebuttal to the cardholder's claims

Evidence alone is not a response under 13.3. You need the proof and a written rebuttal addressing what the cardholder actually said. That is a real difference from merchandise not received, where proof of delivery with a full address stands on its own.

You may also respond with evidence that the cardholder did not attempt to return the merchandise, or certification that returned merchandise has not been received.

From 23 October 2027 You Must Name the Rule

Through 22 October 2027 you can respond that "the Dispute is invalid". From 23 October 2027 the rule names what you have to point at: Section 11.11.4.3 for an invalid dispute, or a failure to meet the requirements in Section 11.11.4.5.

The same pointer requirement is arriving across fifteen conditions and is covered in the 2027 dispute response changes. The practical effect for 13.3 is that a bare assertion stops working, and you will need to cite the specific certification the issuer skipped.

What To Fix This Week

  1. Make your returns instructions unambiguous and keep a dated copy of what the page said. Four of the five valid-attempt triggers are merchant conduct, and "did not provide clear instructions on how to return" is the one most likely to be true by accident.
  2. Never refuse a return without recording why, because refusing removes the issuer's 15 day waiting period.
  3. If you sell over the phone in the US, assume verbal descriptions are in scope and keep recordings.
  4. Build a rebuttal template. Under 13.3 your evidence is only half a response.
  5. Track open customer disputes against the 120 day mark, because a negotiation that starts inside it can extend the chargeback window by 60 days from a notification you will not see coming.

The amount at stake is limited to the unused portion of a cancelled service or the value of the merchandise returned or attempted to be returned, which is the proportionality rule covered in partial disputes. Submitting the response itself is in chargeback representment, and your disclosed policy matters here as much as it does in refund policy disclosure.

FAQ

Does the customer have to return the item before disputing?

Yes, under Section 11.11.4.2 the cardholder must return or attempt to return the merchandise, or cancel the services, before the issuer may initiate. An attempt only counts where the merchant refused the return, refused an authorization or label, told the cardholder not to return it, no longer exists or is not responding, or did not give clear return instructions.

Can a restaurant get a 13.3 chargeback for bad food?

No. Section 11.11.4.3 makes a dispute invalid where it concerns the quality of food received from eating places or restaurants, and Visa's own example is a burger received cold.

Is a price complaint a 13.3 dispute?

No. A dispute regarding a price discrepancy is explicitly invalid under 13.3, as is a dispute regarding Value-Added Tax.

How long does a cardholder have to raise a 13.3 dispute?

Normally 120 calendar days from the transaction processing date or from the date they received the goods or services, capped at 540 calendar days. Where there is evidence of ongoing negotiations that began within 120 days of the processing date, the issuer instead has 60 calendar days from the first cardholder notification.

Is proof that the item matched the description enough to win?

Not on its own. Section 11.11.4.6 requires both evidence that the merchandise or service matched the description, or was not damaged or defective, and a merchant rebuttal to the cardholder's claims.

JA

Jeffrey Anderson, Merchant Placement Specialist

Merchant placement specialist at Gray Merchants. Jeffrey works directly with acquiring-bank underwriting teams across the firm’s 70+ banking relationships to place high-risk and hard-to-place businesses, structure multi-MID accounts, and keep flagged merchants processing. His writing draws on the placement files he works every week: what underwriters ask for, why accounts get declined, and what keeps an approved account open.

Talk to a specialist

Tell us about your business

Share a few details and a specialist reviews your industry, volume, and processing history, then comes back with the right path. No obligation.

  • Underwriting decision in 24 to 48 hours
  • $0 setup fee, dedicated MID
  • Specialist replies within 4 business hours
  • Every term disclosed in writing before you sign

Request a call from a specialist

Are you currently processing?

No obligation. A specialist replies within 4 business hours.

Defective Goods and Visa's 13.3 Dispute Rules | Gray Merchants