Merchandise Not Received: The Visa 13.1 Dispute Rules
Visa's 13.1 rule says tracking with a partial address is not permitted. Here is what proof of delivery must show and when the dispute is invalid.
By Jeffrey Anderson

- Section 11.11.2.6 (ID# 0030318) requires proof of delivery containing the full delivery address and states that tracking with a partial address is not permitted, which decides most non-receipt disputes on its own.
- A 13.1 dispute can arrive up to 120 calendar days from the transaction processing date or from the last expected delivery date, capped at 540 calendar days, so long lead times need evidence retention past eighteen months.
- Section 11.11.2.3 (ID# 0030315) makes the dispute invalid for quality complaints, pre-delivery cancellations including buyer's remorse, transactions the cardholder calls fraudulent, fuel dispenser transactions and merchandise held in the cardholder's country's customs.
- The cardholder must attempt to resolve with the merchant before the issuer may initiate, and from 23 October 2027 the issuer must certify the date, the contact details used and the outcome.
- A cardholder letter is required when the same card has produced three or more non-receipt disputes at the same merchant inside one 30 calendar day period.
- Collected goods need a pick up document with the cardholder's acknowledgment, a signature, PIN or collection code, and crypto or NFT delivery needs the destination wallet address or a blockchain hash that is searchable on an open-source website.
Merchandise not received is the most common dispute an ecommerce merchant sees, and the rule that governs it has one line that decides most cases. When you respond with proof of delivery, Visa requires "proof of delivery that contains the full delivery address", and adds in the same breath that "tracking with partial address is not permitted".
A bare tracking number is not a defence. A tracking number showing delivery to a city and ZIP is not a defence. The full address has to be on the document you submit.
That is Section 11.11.2.6 of the Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (ID# 0030318), and it was last updated in October 2026. Below is the rest of the condition, because knowing what the issuer has to prove is worth as much as knowing what you have to.
What Dispute 13.1 Actually Alleges
The reason is narrow. Section 11.11.2.1 (ID# 0030313) allows a dispute where the cardholder "participated in the Transaction but the Cardholder or an authorized person did not receive the merchandise or services because the Merchant or Load Partner was unwilling or unable to provide the merchandise or services".
Note what that excludes. The cardholder participated. So this is not a fraud claim, and a transaction the cardholder calls fraudulent cannot come through 13.1. Note also "unwilling or unable", which is about your capacity to deliver rather than the quality of what arrived.
The Cardholder Has to Come to You First
Section 11.11.2.2 (ID# 0030314) sets the dispute rights, and the first one is the one merchants most often do not know: "Before the Issuer may initiate a Dispute, the Cardholder must attempt to resolve the Dispute with the Merchant, the Merchant's liquidator, Ramp Provider, or its Conversion Affiliate as applicable."
Three more conditions sit alongside it:
- The dispute amount is limited to the portion of services or merchandise not received, which is the same proportionality principle covered in partial disputes.
- If merchandise was delivered late, the cardholder must return or attempt to return it.
- The merchant is responsible for merchandise held in a customs agency in the merchant's country.
That last one has a mirror image in the invalid list below, and the pair is worth holding together. Customs in your country is your problem. Customs in the cardholder's country is not.
Nine Ways the Dispute Is Invalid
Section 11.11.2.3 (ID# 0030315) is the most useful part of the condition for a merchant, because every item is a defence. A 13.1 dispute is invalid for any of:
- An ATM cash disbursement
- A straight through processing transaction
- A transaction the cardholder cancelled before the expected delivery or service date. Visa's own example is buyer's remorse.
- Merchandise being held by the customs agency of the cardholder's country
- A transaction the cardholder states is fraudulent
- A dispute about the quality of merchandise or service, which belongs under 13.3 rather than here
- A partial advance payment transaction where the remaining balance was not paid and the merchant is willing and able to provide
- The cash-back portion of a cash-back transaction
- An automated fuel dispenser transaction
For crypto there is a tenth. If the non-fiat currency or NFT was successfully delivered and the cardholder simply cannot access it afterwards, for example cannot withdraw winnings or make a transfer, the dispute is invalid. The delivery is what Visa measures, not what happened next. The surrounding rules for that model are in ramp providers and conversion affiliates.
The Clock Runs Longer Than You Think
Section 11.11.2.4 (ID# 0030316) sets the timings. The issuer must wait 15 calendar days from whichever applies: the transaction date where no expected delivery or service date was specified, the date the cardholder returned or attempted to return late merchandise, or the date you cancelled the goods or services. For MCC 4722 travel agencies and tour operators, and ticket agencies selling third-party event tickets, the wait is 30 calendar days from the date the service provider cancelled.
The waiting period is waived if it would push the dispute past its own deadline, and waived entirely if the merchant is insolvent or bankrupt.
Then the outer limit. A dispute must be processed no later than 120 calendar days from the transaction processing date, or 120 calendar days from the last date the cardholder expected to receive the merchandise or services. The second branch is the one that catches people out, because a footnote caps it at 540 calendar days from the transaction processing date.
So on a pre-order or a long lead time, a 13.1 dispute can arrive up to about eighteen months after the sale. If you sell anything with a distant delivery date, your evidence retention policy needs to reach that far, not twelve months.
What the Issuer Has to Prove
Section 11.11.2.5 (ID# 0030317) lists what the issuer must certify, and a dispute that skips any of it is one you can challenge. The issuer certifies which failure occurred, and for a location failure must give "the full and complete address of the agreed location, including street address, city, state/province, and postal code [or country equivalent] and country".
The issuer must also provide what the rule calls "A detailed description of the merchandise or services purchased", and Visa is explicit that this has to go beyond the clearing record. Its own illustration: the merchant's MCC is 5651 Family Clothing Stores and the description states a pair of blue jeans.
Two more worth knowing:
- If the dispute was initiated before the expected delivery date, the issuer must explain why.
- A cardholder letter is required where the cardholder has disputed three or more non-receipt transactions at the same merchant on the same card, and all of them fell within the same 30 calendar day period.
That last provision is a serial-disputer check, and it is in the rules for your benefit. If the same card has hit you three times in a month for non-receipt, the issuer owes a letter.
What Changes on 23 October 2027
Two dated changes sit inside this condition, and both tighten the issuer's side.
For disputes processed through 22 October 2027, the issuer certifies simply that the "Cardholder attempted to resolve with Merchant". For disputes processed on or after 23 October 2027, the issuer must certify that and both of two further items: "The date the Cardholder attempted to resolve", and "Details used to contact the Merchant, such as an email address, telephone number, or physical address, and the outcome of the attempt to resolve".
The response side mirrors it. Through 22 October 2027 you can respond that "the Dispute is invalid". From 23 October 2027 the rule names what you must point at: Section 11.11.2.3 for an invalid dispute, or a failure to meet Section 11.11.2.5. That is the same pointer requirement spreading across fifteen conditions, covered in the 2027 dispute response changes.
Your Response Options in Full
Section 11.11.2.6 (ID# 0030318) accepts evidence of any one of the following:
- A credit or reversal you issued that the issuer did not address in the dispute
- The dispute is invalid
- The cardholder no longer disputes the transaction
- The cardholder or an authorized person received the services at the agreed location or by the agreed date and time
- For merchandise, receipt at the agreed location or by the agreed date and time
For that last one, the accepted proof depends on how the goods moved. Delivered merchandise needs proof of delivery with the full delivery address. Card-absent merchandise that was collected needs a pick up document including acknowledgment from the cardholder or an authorized person, and Visa gives signature, PIN or collection code as examples. Card-present needs certification that the cardholder took the merchandise at the time of sale.
Three special cases round it out. For an airline transaction where the cardholder says the flight did not happen, evidence that the flight departed. For future services, evidence that you did not cancel and the services were available. For crypto and NFTs, evidence of successful delivery to the destination wallet address the cardholder supplied at the time of the transaction, plus the wallet address, a blockchain transaction hash, or both, and Visa requires the hash to be "searchable/traceable on an open-source website".
What To Fix This Week
- Check what your proof of delivery actually prints. If your carrier integration returns a tracking status without the full street address, that evidence does not meet the rule, and no amount of compelling evidence elsewhere repairs it.
- For anything collected rather than shipped, make sure the pick up record captures a signature, PIN or collection code tied to the person collecting.
- Extend evidence retention past 540 days if you sell with long lead times.
- Read incoming 13.1 disputes against the invalid list before writing a response. Quality complaints, cardholder-side customs holds, pre-delivery cancellations and fuel dispenser transactions are all misfiled by default.
The mechanics of submitting the response itself are in chargeback representment, and the distinction between a dispute, a chargeback and a plain refund is in chargeback vs refund vs dispute.
FAQ
Is a tracking number enough to win a 13.1 dispute?
No. Section 11.11.2.6 requires proof of delivery containing the full delivery address and states that tracking with a partial address is not permitted.
How long after a sale can a 13.1 dispute arrive?
Up to 120 calendar days from the transaction processing date, or 120 calendar days from the last date the cardholder expected delivery, with an outer cap of 540 calendar days from the transaction processing date.
Does the cardholder have to contact me before disputing?
Yes. Section 11.11.2.2 requires the cardholder to attempt to resolve with the merchant before the issuer may initiate. From 23 October 2027 the issuer must also certify the date of that attempt, the contact details used, and the outcome.
Can a 13.1 dispute be used for faulty goods?
No. A dispute regarding the quality of merchandise or service is explicitly invalid under 13.1. That belongs under Dispute Condition 13.3.
What if the parcel is stuck in customs?
It depends whose customs. You are responsible for merchandise held in a customs agency in your own country. A dispute is invalid where the merchandise is held by the customs agency of the cardholder's country.
Jeffrey Anderson, Merchant Placement Specialist
Merchant placement specialist at Gray Merchants. Jeffrey works directly with acquiring-bank underwriting teams across the firm’s 70+ banking relationships to place high-risk and hard-to-place businesses, structure multi-MID accounts, and keep flagged merchants processing. His writing draws on the placement files he works every week: what underwriters ask for, why accounts get declined, and what keeps an approved account open.